Recently I have been fascinated by the asset allocation method of the Permanent Portfolio. This portfolio was created by Harry Browne back in the 1970s and truthfully the results of it has been amazing while the simplicity of it is dumbfounding. The basic premise of the Permanent Portfolio is to have various asset classes that perform well under all economic circumstances. There are only four economic situations that the United States is in one time or another: prosperity, inflation, deflation/depression, and recession. And for each of these situations, there is an asset class that excels under it, respectively: stocks, gold, long-term treasury bonds, and short-term bills/cash. The excelling asset class has almost always increased many times over compared to the other asset classes that might be falling. Thus, if you have all four, you encompass the entire market while also making a positive return.
But you might be wondering why do we need these four asset classes that perform differently under different economic circumstances. The explanation is simple: We don’t know what is going to happen in the future. The talking-heads on television don’t know what is going to happen in the future. Everyday we hear conflicting stories about impending deflation, runaway inflation, or struggling green shoots. The truth of it is, we just don’t know. We don’t know what is going to happen 1, 5 or 10 years from now. No one can accurately predict tomorrow and hindsight is 20/20. So the best strategy is to plan for all economic circumstances as if they might come to roost. So we dab 25% into stocks in case of prosperity. We throw another 25% into gold to hedge against runaway inflation. We allocate 25% into long-term treasury bonds in the situation of impending deflation. And if we have the transitionary state of recession, we will have 25% in cash/short-term bills to keep us worry-free at night.
At first glance, this might seem crazy. I sure thought so. The Permanent Portfolio advocates putting 25% of your investments into each of the four asset classes: stocks, gold, long-term treasury bonds, and short-term bills/cash. Wha??? 25% of your investment into the commodity Gold??!! Yea, that’s how I reacted too. But it is important to reflect that the strength in this portfolio allocation method is the unity of the four asset classes. When one falls, another will inevitably rise, offsetting the difference while also exceeding it into the positive return territory. You cannot think of each asset class individually, rather you need to think of it as one entire package that works together. Take out one, and we are leaving ourselves vulnerable to that corresponding economic condition.
In addition, a luring aspect of the Permanent Portfolio is the fact that it was created a long time ago, it is not some theory that was backtested and invented a year ago. For the last thirty or so years that it has been in existence, the results are astounding. The annualized returns have been around the 9.5% range with very minimal volatility (the greatest drop was 6% back in 1981). So with this asset allocation you can get pretty good returns while not have gut-wrenching rollercoaster rides.
After doing numerous research about this on the boglehead forums, listening to Harry Browne’s radio recordings, and reading about it in various informative websites, I believe this allocation method is sound. I just makes sense. I’ve tried counter-arguments but cannot come up with a scenario in which this doesn’t work. If you really think about it, if anything really bad happens to the market, is the typical stock/bond allocation method going to cut it? No I don’t think so — October 2008 sure taught us that lesson very well. So if we cover all our bases and rebalance every once in a while, this portfolio will help keep us sane. Currently I have been reorganizing my investments to correspond to the Permanent Portfolio. Unfortunately I cannot buy real gold and only the ETF GLD. Also, I am buying the Vanguard Long-Term Treasury fund for the long-term bond portion. I will give updates on how this is going on a yearly basis. And if you want more information, check out the website CrawlingRoad.
